New era · up to 30% off today · Shop the sale

Signings, craft nights & book clubs · See events

Free pickup at the shop in Hayden, Idaho


Use coupon code WELCOME10 for 10% off your first order.

Cart 0

Congratulations! Your order qualifies for free shipping You are $0 away from free shipping.
Sorry, looks like we don't have enough of this product.

Pair with
Is this a gift?
Subtotal Free
View cart
Shipping, taxes, and discount codes are calculated at checkout

Your Cart is Empty

blind date with a book

Don't judge a book by its cover. You can't.

A real book from our shelves, wrapped in paper, with only the clue codes on the tag. You don't get the title until you open it.

Half the fun of a bookstore is walking out with something you didn't come in for. This is that, on purpose. Tell us what you're in the mood for, or take the quiz and let it decide, and our staff picks a book we think you'll love. Paperback or hardcover, on its own or with a box of goodies from the shop. No cover to overthink. No reviews to scroll. Just a good story showing up at your door.

  • Hand-pickedby our staff
  • 20reader types
  • From $19.99paperback, hardcover or deluxe
why we love this

Three good reasons to go in blind

reading slump

You don't know what to read

You've been staring at your TBR for a week. Let someone else choose for once. We read these books, we talk about them all day, and we're good at this.

the cover trap

Covers lie

Some of the best books on our shelves have the quietest covers. Going in blind means you meet the story first and the marketing second.

gift it

The easiest gift for a reader

Pick the shelf that sounds like them, add a note at checkout, and we'll wrap it. Go deluxe and it arrives in a box with goodies from the shop. A surprise book beats a gift card every time.

how it works

Three steps, one surprise

  1. 1

    Find your match

    Take the same quiz we run on the TV in the shop, plus a few extra questions only our staff see: books you've loved, authors you already collect, a Goodreads link if you have one. Or skip it and pick a shelf and heat level yourself.

  2. 2

    We pick the book

    Your code, reader type and clue tropes come through on the order. We check your Read shelf if you shared one, pick a book from that shelf at that heat, and steer around anything you noted.

  3. 3

    Unwrap it

    It arrives in paper with the clues on the tag. Deluxe dates come in a box with goodies from the shop. Open it when you're ready, then come tell us if we got it right.

same quiz as the shop, fresh every visit

Find your match

Sixteen questions, a fresh set every time you come back. It sorts you into one of twenty reader types and hands you an order button.

two minutes, sixteen questions Answer a few questions and we'll match you with your perfect read. We pick the book, wrap it, and send it your way. Start the quiz

Already know your type? Pick your shelf below.

wrapped and waiting

On the shelf right now

See every blind date →
good to know

Questions people ask

What if I already own the book?

Leave a note at checkout with anything you own or don't want, and we'll steer around it. If it still happens, bring it in unopened and we'll swap it.

Can I choose the heat level?

Yes. Every shelf comes in five heat levels, Vanilla to Ghost Pepper. Pick it on the product page, or take the quiz and it sets the heat for you.

Paperback or hardcover?

Your choice. Every date comes as a paperback ($19.99) or a hardcover ($32.99). Hardcover picks depend on what we have on the shelf in hardcover, so the pool is a little smaller.

What's in the deluxe box?

The wrapped book plus a few goodies from the shop, packed in a box. Deluxe paperback is $28.99 and deluxe hardcover is $38.99. The goodies change with the seasons.

How do you know I haven't read it?

The quiz asks for a Goodreads, StoryGraph or Fable link, plus books you've loved and authors you collect. If your shelves are public we check your Read shelf before we wrap. Only our staff see any of it.

Can I send one as a gift?

Yes. Add the recipient's address at checkout and a gift message in the order note. The clue tag goes on the outside, so it's a surprise for them too.

Can I pick one up in the shop?

Yes. Choose pickup at checkout and it'll be wrapped and waiting at the counter in Hayden, usually within a day.