Free pickup in Hayden, Idaho · Signings, craft nights & book clubs · See events

Shop the Holiday Gift Guide · Order by Dec 15 for Christmas delivery

Cart 0

Sorry, looks like we don't have enough of this product.

Pair with
Add order notes
Is this a gift?
Subtotal Free
View cart
Shipping, taxes, and discount codes are calculated at checkout

Your Cart is Empty

Stocking Stuffers 38

Filters

No filters available for this collection
View 38 items
Mountain Madness Bath Bomb
 

Mountain Madness Bath Bomb

$6.00
Festive But Stabby - Mirrored Knife Bookmark: Red
 
Sold Out

Festive But Stabby - Mirrored Knife Bookmark: Red

Sold Out
Romance Reader Enamel Keychain
 
Romance Reader Enamel Keychain
Romance Reader Enamel Keychain

Romance Reader Enamel Keychain

$14.00
Bookish Baddie | Bookish Candle | Book Themed Soy Wax: 4 oz
 
Bookish Baddie | Bookish Candle | Book Themed Soy Wax: 4 oz
Bookish Baddie | Bookish Candle | Book Themed Soy Wax: 4 oz

Bookish Baddie | Bookish Candle | Book Themed Soy Wax: 4 oz

$12.00
Slide image
 
Bookish Holiday Pen Set – 4-Pack Christmas Click Pens
Bookish Holiday Pen Set – 4-Pack Christmas Click Pens

Bookish Holiday Pen Set – 4-Pack Christmas Click Pens

$12.00
Mountain Madness Soap
 
Mountain Madness Soap
Mountain Madness Soap

Mountain Madness Soap

$14.00
Stabby Holidays (Gothic Font) - Mirrored Knife Bookmark: Red
 

Stabby Holidays (Gothic Font) - Mirrored Knife Bookmark: Red

$12.00
Note to Shelf Notepad | Bookish Stationery Gift
 

Note to Shelf Notepad | Bookish Stationery Gift

$10.00
Slide image
 
Fourth Wing | Riders Quadrant Location Keychain
Fourth Wing | Riders Quadrant Location Keychain

Fourth Wing | Riders Quadrant Location Keychain

$14.00
Bless Your Bookish Heart - Bookish Candle | Book Themed 4oz
 
Bless Your Bookish Heart - Bookish Candle | Book Themed 4oz
Bless Your Bookish Heart - Bookish Candle | Book Themed 4oz

Bless Your Bookish Heart - Bookish Candle | Book Themed 4oz

$12.00
'Tis The Season for Slaying - Mirrored Knife Bookm: Dark Green
 

'Tis The Season for Slaying - Mirrored Knife Bookm: Dark Green

$12.00
Slide image
 
Merry & Bright Reading Time – Book Lovers Christmas Card
Merry & Bright Reading Time – Book Lovers Christmas Card

Merry & Bright Reading Time – Book Lovers Christmas Card

$5.50
Ride It - Knife Bookmark
 
Ride It - Knife Bookmark
Ride It - Knife Bookmark

Ride It - Knife Bookmark

$12.00
Don't Hate Me, Turns Me On - Mirrored Knife Bookmark: Pink
 
Don't Hate Me, Turns Me On - Mirrored Knife Bookmark: Pink
Don't Hate Me, Turns Me On - Mirrored Knife Bookmark: Pink

Don't Hate Me, Turns Me On - Mirrored Knife Bookmark: Pink

$12.00
Freaky and Frosty (Script) - Mirrored Knife Bookma: Blue
 

Freaky and Frosty (Script) - Mirrored Knife Bookma: Blue

$12.00
He See's You When You're Sleeping - Mirrored Knife: Lime
 

He See's You When You're Sleeping - Mirrored Knife: Lime

$12.00
Villains Fuck Better - Mirrored Knife Bookmark: Red
 
Villains Fuck Better - Mirrored Knife Bookmark: Red
Villains Fuck Better - Mirrored Knife Bookmark: Red

Villains Fuck Better - Mirrored Knife Bookmark: Red

$12.00
Fantasy Reader Enamel Keychain
 
Fantasy Reader Enamel Keychain
Fantasy Reader Enamel Keychain

Fantasy Reader Enamel Keychain

$14.00
I'd Rather Be Reading Enamel Keychain
 

I'd Rather Be Reading Enamel Keychain

$14.00
Waiting To Be Kidnapped By Faeries Enamel Keychain
 
Waiting To Be Kidnapped By Faeries Enamel Keychain
Waiting To Be Kidnapped By Faeries Enamel Keychain

Waiting To Be Kidnapped By Faeries Enamel Keychain

$14.00
Slide image
 

Zodiac Academy Defy The Stars Motel Keychain

$9.00
Slide image
 
Winters Moon Hard Enamel Keychain
Winters Moon Hard Enamel Keychain

Winters Moon Hard Enamel Keychain

$14.00
Slide image
 
Cauldron Hard Enamel Keychain
Cauldron Hard Enamel Keychain

Cauldron Hard Enamel Keychain

$14.00
Fully Booked Keychain
 

Fully Booked Keychain

$15.00

Continue shopping

Best sellers

See all
Daggermouth Deluxe Daggermouth Deluxe $34.00
The Knave and The Moon by Rachel Gillig The Knave and The Moon by Rachel Gillig $30.00
Devour Me Devour Me $22.00
Storm of Secrets and Sorrow by Melissa K. Roehrich Storm of Secrets and Sorrow by Melissa K. Roehrich $32.00
God of Malice by Rina Kent God of Malice by Rina Kent $18.99
Us Deadly Few Us Deadly Few $21.99
Steelborn (Deluxe Limited Edition) Steelborn (Deluxe Limited Edition) $32.00
The Goal (Collector's Edition) The Goal (Collector's Edition) $31.99
Hate Me Take Me by Laura Bishop Hate Me Take Me by Laura Bishop $19.00
The Splintered Kingdom by Gretchen Powell Fox The Splintered Kingdom by Gretchen Powell Fox $33.00
For authors Your book belongs on a real shelf. We stock, hand-sell, and host romance authors. Indie and traditional, all subgenres, all heat levels. Submit your book What we look for
Visit the shop The café Events Plot Fest Pre-orders Blind date with a book Shop by author Spice levels Gift cards FAQ Contact After Dark
Stay in the story New releases, special editions and event news, sent to your inbox.

8927 N Hess St, Ste A · Hayden, ID 83835
(208) 772-5053 · hello@lovestorybooksandcafe.com

Mon–Wed 9am–6pm · Thu–Fri 7am–6pm
Sat & Sun 10am–5pm

Privacy Returns Shipping Terms

© 2026 It's a Love Story®. All rights reserved.

Ask a bookseller