Free pickup in Hayden, Idaho · Signings, craft nights & book clubs · See events

Shop the Holiday Gift Guide · Order by Dec 15 for Christmas delivery


Cart 1

Sorry, looks like we don't have enough of this product.

Pair with
Add order notes
Is this a gift?
Subtotal $22.99 USD
View cart
Shipping, taxes, and discount codes are calculated at checkout

Your Cart is Empty


When Forever Falls Apart -  (Paperback)
Regular price $19.00
Shipping calculated at checkout.
About this book

A runaway bride returns to her small town, hoping to let go of the past, and ends up embroiling her best friend's older brother in a fake-dating plot to make her ex jealous--from the bestselling author of How to Break My Heart.

Maddy Beaumont has been dubbed the runaway bride of Cinnamon Springs after leaving her ex, Myles, jilted at the aisle and escaping to Europe. But she can't escape the townspeople's judgment for long. Months later, she's forced to return home and face reality, and Maddy is surprised by feelings of regret when she learns Myles has a new girlfriend so soon.

Did she make a mistake by calling off the wedding? There's only one way to find out. When Maddy is invited to an event with Myles in attendance, she strikes a deal with pastry chef Elliot, her best friend's charming older brother. For one night, Elliot and Maddy are going to pretend they're dating. Easy, right? Just hold each other's hand and pretend to look in love.

But the more time Maddy spends with Elliot, the more she realizes what they share might not be so fake after all.

When Forever Falls Apart

$19.00

Continue shopping

Best sellers

See all
For authors Your book belongs on a real shelf. We stock, hand-sell, and host romance authors. Indie and traditional, all subgenres, all heat levels. Submit your book What we look for
Stay in the story New releases, special editions and event news, sent to your inbox.

8927 N Hess St, Ste A · Hayden, ID 83835
(208) 772-5053 · hello@lovestorybooksandcafe.com

Mon–Wed 9am–6pm · Thu–Fri 7am–6pm
Sat & Sun 10am–5pm

Privacy Returns Shipping Terms

© 2026 It's a Love Story®. All rights reserved.

Ask a bookseller