Free pickup in Hayden, Idaho · Signings, craft nights & book clubs · See events

Shop the Holiday Gift Guide · Order by Dec 15 for Christmas delivery


Cart 1

Sorry, looks like we don't have enough of this product.

Pair with
Add order notes
Is this a gift?
Subtotal $18.99 USD
View cart
Shipping, taxes, and discount codes are calculated at checkout

Your Cart is Empty


Mistletoe and Mishigas- M.A. Wardell

Mistletoe and Mishigas by M.A. Wardell

by M.A. Wardell

Regular price $17.99
Shipping calculated at checkout.
About this book

Two men with opposite personalities fake date during the holidays in this steamy romance that's perfect for fans of Casey McQuiston and Anita Kelly.


Now including a new epilogue and bonus artwork of the characters!


"M.A. Wardell's stories are sweetness and spice wrapped into a big, warm hug." ―Alice Oseman, bestselling author of Heartstopper


Sheldon Soleskin should be having a horrible day. Even though he's been unexpectedly transferred to a new school right before the holidays, has only one day to set up his new classroom, and just discovered his twin sister's been hiding an invitation to his ex-boyfriend's Christmas Eve wedding, he's still ready to take on the world with a smile on his face and a skip in his step.


Theo Berenson just wants to be left alone to his custodial duties. But when the chipper new first-grade teacher needs help moving furniture the Sunday after Thanksgiving, he's forced to do something he detests ... help. To make matters worse, Theo's overbearing parents are coming for Hanukah in a few weeks, and he's told them he has a boyfriend. Except he doesn't. Because who would want to date an oaf like Theo?


Working together, these opposites discover they might be able to help each other out. Agreeing to be each other's dates, they become friends as they practice for their upcoming events. But when all the rehearsing starts feeling a little too real, and both men's pasts come roaring back to haunt them, will they be able to pull off the ultimate holiday masquerade?


"Sheldon and Theo's opposites-attract, Beauty-and-the-Beast chemistry grabbed me from the first chapter and never let go. Wholly delightful and full of Hanukkah spirit--Wardell's voice jumps off the page."--Anita Kelly, author of Something Wild and Wonderful

Mistletoe and Mishigas by M.A. Wardell

$17.99

Continue shopping

Best sellers

See all
For authors Your book belongs on a real shelf. We stock, hand-sell, and host romance authors. Indie and traditional, all subgenres, all heat levels. Submit your book What we look for
Stay in the story New releases, special editions and event news, sent to your inbox.

8927 N Hess St, Ste A · Hayden, ID 83835
(208) 772-5053 · hello@lovestorybooksandcafe.com

Mon–Wed 9am–6pm · Thu–Fri 7am–6pm
Sat & Sun 10am–5pm

Privacy Returns Shipping Terms

© 2026 It's a Love Story®. All rights reserved.

Ask a bookseller